Skip to main content

Beyond Blue Sky 2025 - Chapter 4a

Economic Growth Tension

A clear tension exists between carbon emissions and economic growth since the latter depended on cheap fossil fuels for the past two centuries - with low-cost energy fundamental to growth.  The challenge then is to 'decouple' effectively growth from carbon emissions and so guarantee a clean energy future.

Integrated Assessment Models would argue here that we need optimal carbon taxes to effect this but these, in turn, would increase the costs of travel, food, and goods at least in the short run.  Two fundamental problems that would need to be addressed here are 1) international cooperation and 2) internal wealth transfers to the poor in society.  Of course, if we can access cheaper renewable energy then this, too, could be a driver of economic growth.

Economic Growth

In the last version of this book, this current chapter focuses on Economic Growth and agrees with Lord Stern (2009) that growth of the 'right kind' is needed, i.e. a move away from consumerism towards manufacture.  He wrote:

"This is not to claim that the world can continue to grow indefinitely.  It is not even clear what such a claim would involve: societies, living standards, and ways of producing and consuming all develop and change.  A picture of indefinite expansion is an implausible story of the future, but two things are key: first, to find a way of increasing living standards (including health, education, and freedoms) so that world poverty can be overcome, and second, to discover ways of living that can be sustained over time, particularly concerning the environment.  Strong growth, of the right kind, will be both necessary and feasible for many decades (Stern, 2009, A Blueprint for a Safer Planet, Random House, London).

Limits and Beyond

However, before we can predict decades ahead, we need to address the present malaise in The West where growth is stalling, and, according to The Club of Rome, societal collapse is due about now as was predicted in their landmark report in 1972.  I am currently reading the 2022 book entitled "Limits and Beyond", reflecting on the past 50 years since the 1972 Report and computer model.  Although this book is already 3 years old, it holds value for 2025 as we witness, in particular, a looming recession in the US - the biggest economy in the world. 

I will update this blog once I have read the book!  One thing is certain: BP's current "reset strategy" begun on 25 February 2025, is wrong in that it focuses almost exclusively on fossil fuels.  Too little capital is allocated to the transition which, as I have mentioned already, we have little time to bring about.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Beyond Blue Sky 2025 - Chapter 3b - Life!

Live life abundantly!  (John 10:10). What To Do About Climate Change? The fundamental problem is that carbon emissions are so inexorably linked to economic activity (IT, housing, agriculture, manufacturing, and transport) that reducing them and operating a 'green' economy is no small task.  Thinking negatively, economy derailment could be the solution - although to be positive the focus should be a major change along the continuum of slowing, stabilizing, and reducing CO2 emissions within a fully functioning economy, which runs counter to many environmentalists' thinking.  However, we definitely need a new economy based on a clean-energy future. We are, truly, in a Climate Emergency.  As outlined throughout, unless bold action is taken to change the economic system while carbon budgets allow, we may well be facing a long drawn-out equivalent of the sudden extinction of the dinosaurs 66 million years ago - and certainly the worst set of circumstances since The Flood i...
Post a Comment
Read more

Beyond Blue Sky 2025 - Chapter 2b

Climate Sensitivity Quantifying temperature increase in relation to CO2 volume depends on 'climate sensitivity'.  Commonly, this refers to temperature increase resulting from CO2 doubling since the pre-industrial times atmospheric baseline of 280ppm to approx. 550ppm.  The IPCC models predict a range of 2C to 4.5C above 1900, with a best estimate of 3C.  As of June 2024, the world is currently at 427ppm and 1.55C above 1900. Although both temperature and atmosphere water vapor will continue to increase, specific impacts will depend on geographical location.  For example, higher latitudes together with mid-continental locations are expected to warm sooner and faster.  Also, high rainfall areas should get wetter contrasting drier drought-prone regions.  Much modeling is in progress to predict these regional impacts in greater detail, although we mustn't also forget that it is ultimately God who sends the rains.  The challenge of climate change, particula...
Post a Comment
Read more

Beyond Blue Sky 2025 - Chapter 3a

Dangerous Climate Change Based on the best available scientific evidence, it is clear that increases in CO2, and other greenhouse gases in CO2e (carbon dioxide equivalent), which constitute F in the Kaya Identity (see earlier), result in temperature elevation.  The relationship between the two is known as climate sensitivity.  It is accepted by most scientists that a CO2 doubling (from pre-industrial 280ppm to 550ppm) will probably lead to a roughly 3C temperature rise.  The IPCC calculated a range of 1.5C and 4.5C depending on the emission scenario.  Unfortunately, this is far from exact since fossil records estimate that climate sensitivity could be as high as 6C (Hansen). Are temperature increases dangerous? The overriding consensus is a resounding yes.  There is no question that biomes, including pathogenic species, would survive and even proliferate.  The concern is that widespread ecosystem collapse would occur specifically concerning biomes on which ...
Post a Comment
Read more